{
  "schemaVersion": "4.1",
  "tuples": [
    {
      "schemaVersion": "4.1",
      "tupleId": "rehearsal-table-2-public-teaching-sample-v1",
      "claim": {
        "localDocumentId": "public-teaching-sample",
        "localRevisionId": "public-teaching-sample-v1",
        "filePath": "citation-review-sample.tex",
        "astNodeId": "doc-citation-review-sample.tex",
        "atomicClaimId": "rehearsal-vaswani2017attention",
        "exactText": "Transformer (big) achieves 29.4 BLEU on EN-DE newstest2014 \\cite{vaswani2017attention}.",
        "spans": [
          {
            "startUtf16": 840,
            "endUtf16Exclusive": 927
          }
        ],
        "citationKeys": [
          "vaswani2017attention"
        ],
        "symbolScopeIds": []
      },
      "citedSource": {
        "kind": "DOI",
        "doi": "10.48550/arxiv.1706.03762",
        "arxivVersion": "1706.03762v7"
      },
      "editorialStatus": {
        "isRetracted": false,
        "lookupTimestamp": "2026-10-12T14:20:29Z",
        "venueTier": "UNKNOWN",
        "checkState": "UNCHECKED"
      },
      "contextComparisons": [
        {
          "dimension": "ENTITY",
          "claimValue": "Transformer (big)",
          "sourceValue": "Transformer (big)",
          "relation": "MATCH",
          "claimSpans": [
            {
              "startUtf16": 840,
              "endUtf16Exclusive": 857
            }
          ],
          "sourceEvidenceIds": [
            "row"
          ]
        },
        {
          "dimension": "METRIC",
          "claimValue": "BLEU",
          "sourceValue": "BLEU",
          "relation": "MATCH",
          "claimSpans": [
            {
              "startUtf16": 872,
              "endUtf16Exclusive": 876
            }
          ],
          "sourceEvidenceIds": [
            "headers"
          ]
        },
        {
          "dimension": "DATASET",
          "claimValue": "EN-DE",
          "sourceValue": "EN-DE",
          "relation": "MATCH",
          "claimSpans": [
            {
              "startUtf16": 880,
              "endUtf16Exclusive": 885
            }
          ],
          "sourceEvidenceIds": [
            "headers"
          ]
        },
        {
          "dimension": "CONDITION",
          "claimValue": "newstest2014",
          "sourceValue": "newstest2014",
          "relation": "MATCH",
          "claimSpans": [
            {
              "startUtf16": 886,
              "endUtf16Exclusive": 898
            }
          ],
          "sourceEvidenceIds": [
            "test-set"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "policyVersion": "rehearsal-scoped-table-comparison/1",
      "modelVersion": null,
      "assessedAt": "2026-10-12T14:20:29Z",
      "sourceState": "AVAILABLE",
      "snapshot": {
        "identity": {
          "kind": "DOI",
          "doi": "10.48550/arxiv.1706.03762",
          "arxivVersion": "1706.03762v7"
        },
        "versionLabel": "1706.03762v7",
        "retrievedAt": "2026-10-12T14:20:29Z",
        "sourceUrl": "https://arxiv.org/html/1706.03762v7",
        "rawContentSha256": "fe1288e9c6f8322156429ab44bf5ced203155f8ecc7ea9fe6cfd125872c72a3b",
        "evidenceTextSha256": "435804b68689b510148b6fee527531121fef7bf17603e03946d9c53d1fb1a415",
        "extractorVersion": "preflight-reviewed-table-transcript/1",
        "coverage": "PARTIAL_TEXT",
        "representation": "SOURCE_BYTES"
      },
      "verdict": {
        "kind": "NUMERIC_DISCREPANCY",
        "evidence": [
          {
            "evidenceId": "headers",
            "exactText": "BLEU EN-DE EN-FR",
            "evidenceTextSha256": "435804b68689b510148b6fee527531121fef7bf17603e03946d9c53d1fb1a415",
            "span": {
              "startUtf16": 0,
              "endUtf16Exclusive": 16
            },
            "paragraphId": "table-2-headers",
            "sectionPath": [
              "Results",
              "Machine Translation",
              "Table 2"
            ],
            "contextEvidenceIds": []
          },
          {
            "evidenceId": "row",
            "exactText": "Transformer (big) 28.4 41.8",
            "evidenceTextSha256": "435804b68689b510148b6fee527531121fef7bf17603e03946d9c53d1fb1a415",
            "span": {
              "startUtf16": 17,
              "endUtf16Exclusive": 44
            },
            "paragraphId": "table-2-row",
            "sectionPath": [
              "Results",
              "Machine Translation",
              "Table 2"
            ],
            "contextEvidenceIds": [
              "headers",
              "test-set"
            ],
            "tableCell": {
              "tableId": "2",
              "rowHeader": "Transformer (big)",
              "columnHeader": "BLEU · EN-DE",
              "footnoteEvidenceIds": []
            }
          },
          {
            "evidenceId": "test-set",
            "exactText": "English-to-German and English-to-French newstest2014 tests",
            "evidenceTextSha256": "435804b68689b510148b6fee527531121fef7bf17603e03946d9c53d1fb1a415",
            "span": {
              "startUtf16": 45,
              "endUtf16Exclusive": 103
            },
            "paragraphId": "table-2-test-set",
            "sectionPath": [
              "Results",
              "Machine Translation",
              "Table 2"
            ],
            "contextEvidenceIds": []
          }
        ],
        "deltas": [
          {
            "metric": "BLEU",
            "claimedLiteral": "29.4",
            "sourceLiteral": "28.4",
            "claimInterval": {
              "lowerBound": 29.4,
              "upperBound": 29.4,
              "lowerInclusive": true,
              "upperInclusive": true,
              "representation": "POINT",
              "unit": "BLEU"
            },
            "sourceInterval": {
              "lowerBound": 28.4,
              "upperBound": 28.4,
              "lowerInclusive": true,
              "upperInclusive": true,
              "representation": "POINT",
              "unit": "BLEU"
            },
            "comparisonRuleId": "reviewed-table-2-en-de-point/1",
            "sourceEvidenceIds": [
              "row"
            ],
            "isOverlapping": false,
            "absoluteDelta": 1,
            "relativeDelta": 0.035211267605633804
          }
        ],
        "adjudication": "DETERMINISTIC_COMPARISON"
      },
      "explanation": "The normalized claim and source intervals do not overlap under the same contextual bindings."
    }
  ]
}